Reviews
Part of Seven ways to score talent agencies reviews before you shortlist
When to run a talent agencies selection checklist before you sign
A talent agencies selection checklist for England buyers: what to verify on contracts, disclosure, AI use and fees before you shortlist and sign.
What to take away
- Consumer protection guidance and AI content policies now change what you must ask a talent agency.
- Open the checklist before you shortlist, because preferences harden fast once a favourite appears.
- Score agencies on documents you can verify: contracts, disclosure wording, dated results.
- Refresh the checklist at renewal, since ownership and tooling change between contracts.
Why the checklist moved earlier in the process
The CMA publishes consumer protection guidance for businesses, and that guidance shapes how influencer campaigns are described to audiences. Ask each agency how it applies Consumer protection guidance for businesses to creator content before you compare fees. An agency that cannot answer plainly is a risk you can spot for nothing.
AI tools have changed the questions too. Agencies use models for scripting, editing and reporting, and AI coverage from The Drum shows how quickly those tools reach client work. Your checklist should ask which tools touch drafts, who approves output, and what the contract says about AI-generated assets.
Audience spending shifts as well. Leisure and tourism data from the ONS gives you an independent way to sanity-check an agency's claims about where budgets are going. If the audience story contradicts published spending patterns, ask for the source behind the numbers.
The before and after table
Use one checklist, completed twice. The first pass filters the long list. The second pass tests whether the agency's promises survived contact with your brief. Compare the columns honestly, and note where an answer changed without new evidence. A talent agencies selection checklist only earns its keep at the second pass.
| Stage | Before shortlisting | After shortlisting |
|---|---|---|
| Contract | Notice period, exclusivity and exit wording | Redlines confirmed in writing |
| Disclosure | How paid posts are labelled | Live posts match the label |
| AI use | Which tools touch drafts | Named approver for AI output |
| Reporting | Metrics, date ranges, update rhythm | Raw data behind the summary |
| Fees | Commission and pass-through costs | Invoices against the agreed schedule |
Score the answers, not the pitch
Score each item 0, 1 or 2, where zero means no answer and two means a document you can keep. Then look for gaps rather than totals. An agency with strong reach figures and no disclosure example is a warning, not a winner. The checklist exists to make that gap visible before money moves.
Where the money sits in the checklist
Fees belong on the checklist as a range rather than a single number. For example, a creator paying £400 a month in commission commits £4,800 over a year, before pass-through costs. Ask what sits outside commission: ad spend management, production, legal review. Then compare the same line items across every agency on your list.
Due diligence items that decide the shortlist
Evidence quality decides most shortlists. So does disclosure discipline, and how the agency handles a small paid test. Everything else is preference. Work through reviews and comparison methods for 2027 before you score anything, because a scoring sheet without a method becomes a popularity vote.
What to ask for in writing
Request a sample contract, a disclosure example from the last quarter, and a named contact for compliance questions. Ask who signs off AI-assisted drafts and how that approval is recorded. Written answers only. A verbal assurance about process is not evidence, and it will not help you at renewal.
What to test with a small brief
Give two agencies the same small brief: one paid post, one deadline, one reporting format. Compare the response time, the questions they ask, and the accuracy of the first invoice. Two weeks is usually enough to see how an agency works. A short paid test costs less than a twelve-month contract you regret. Best providers in England is a useful cross-check on which agencies match your category.
Common questions
When should I complete the checklist?
Before you ask for proposals, and again before you sign. The second pass is where most buyers find the gap between a pitch and a contract.
Does a small agency need the same checklist?
Yes, with less depth on reporting. Small agencies often answer compliance questions faster than large ones, so score the answer, not the headcount.
How often should I refresh it?
At every renewal and whenever an agency changes ownership, tooling or its AI policy. Contract terms drift quietly.
What if an agency refuses to answer?
Treat a refusal as a signal. Ask for the specific clause or policy instead. If nothing arrives in writing, move to the next name on the list.
